Questioning

I was told recently that my habit of questioning everything is corrosive to my life. At first, I was a little taken aback at the time and kind of laughed it off, now that I’ve spent some time thinking about it, I’m going to say that person was quite wrong about the whole situation. (And if that person is reading this blog, no hard feelings about it, but I still don’t agree with you.)

Questioning is that which keeps us from taking too many steps in the wrong direction (that is assuming that you feel like questioning isn’t the FIRST step in the wrong direction.) Questioning enables us to find the truest source, or reasoning, behind an action, thought, or belief. While I think most people would agree that we should question, the issue comes down to what we should question.

Me? I think Everything.

Growing up, I was always taught to question everything in light of the Bible, or specifically via the biblical lens that was instilled in me through the Baptist church. I was never told that questioning the Bible is OK, and I’m fairly certain that those who trained me would be rather disappointed with my ability (and you could even say desire) to do so. Without the questions like “Is the Bible accurate,” or “Do I actually believe this,” I’d probably still be sitting as some angry guy who has no appreciation for the Bible whatsoever.

Now I’m in the habit of questioning everything, it’s not something I even think about anymore, I question basically everything I hear. Does questioning everything lead me down a destructive path? I don’t think so. Actually, I’m willing to state that the opposite effect is had. I’m no longer so easily swayed that anyone I listen to that makes a statement with certainty is believed. Instead what they say must be broken down, rationalized out, and tested before it’s accepted. If we all questioned, we’d end up with a well thought out set of beliefs instead of an impenetrable wall of certainties.

I think I’ll stop there for tonight, and leave the distinction between belief and knowledge for another day.

Now, pushback if you want.

email2friend
  • My response here will be similar to that I said in person yesterday. You can't help but question some things sometimes. Do I purposefully dissect my relationship with my wife/friends/family? No. If my wife/family/friends does/do something that hurts me, do I question then? Yes. Is that a terrible reaction? I really don't think so.

    Another example: If you dropped me as best man at your wedding, I'd question it... and then I'd hurt you. (I kid, but seriously... don't :P )
  • Andrew
    now that I can agree on. If given a reason to question, then by all means questions.
  • Greg
    i question this blog
  • Nothing to push back on here. The notion that questioning, or the habit of questioning is categorically "corrosive" to one's life strikes me as simply ridiculous. Save the obvious implications that whatever is status quo is inherently correct, how else does one learn? Or become more informed? Or avoid self-imposed ignorance (which is the worst kind)?

    I think you're right. We must constantly question everything. To me, that's what it means to truly "be."
  • Baby Hates Bunnies
    Questioning definitely has it's place. It would be wrong to never question. But if you don't move forward on assumptions, stop questioning for a bit and act on beliefs, you'll be paralyzed.
  • Andrew
    nobody said it was wrong to question. But why question EVERYTHING in your life? The "mystery character" :) in your blog never said questioning was corrosive, but questioning EVERYTHING is. There are some things you shouldn't have to question. Do you question that your wife loves you? do you question that your parents love you? just a question :) oh weird.....question about questions......I'm awesome.
blog comments powered by Disqus
ramblings-theology-my thoughts