The Wall

Sometimes, it’s just so big. You look up, and it never seems to end in that direction, you look to your right, and see it fade in the distance, to your left the same depressing scene plays out. That wall, however, is stopping you from reaching your goal. That wall must come down.

And with a nod to the great poet Lewis Carroll, how do you eat a whale?

I was at work today and made an offhand joke about saving the environment to a co-worker of mine that is a prodigious right wing christian. Were she to read this blog I wouldn’t doubt her thinking I was the anti-christ himself, but that would be giving me too much credit, not enough people like me for that. (On a similar vein, if I hear one more reference that Barack Obama is the antichrist, I might snap).  Back on track now, she had the retort “Only one person can fix the environment, and your not him.”

After my brief “What the f…” moment I lost my opportunity for any sort of retort, so I just let it ride. But let’s upack that statement, and it’s implications if we can.

The most obvious implication is that we fixing our world on our own, becuase it’s the destiny of the world to die. While I’m not denying the evidence of a New Earth written in the New Testament, I am questioning the veracity of this opinion that we should be doing nothing about it now, becuase it’s all going away later. To simplify my response to this as much as humanly possible lets throw this out…

You’re going to die. That is an optimal truth, an inescapable fact. You’re body has come down with a sickness, do you seek to cure it, or do you continue on your merry way knowning full well that you’re going to die eventually?

The next implication is that we are not capable of fixing what we’ve destroyed. While this may be true on more ethereal ideas such as sin, the state of the physical world, while no doubt stemming from a “sinful society,” is something that we can attempt to fix. Maybe the idea is that God wants us to stubbornly continue in the path we’re currently taking and wait for God to fix things, I’m not quite sure there is any Biblical support of this idea it does seem to be quite popular. While, undoubtedly, we are called to wait upon the Lord. Numerous Biblical references can be applied here) we are also called to action (as far as the earth goes the most poignant is in Leviticus 18:

24 ” ‘Do not defile yourselves in any of these ways, because this is how the nations that I am going to drive out before you became defiled. 25 Even the land was defiled; so I punished it for its sin, and the land vomited out its inhabitants. 26 But you must keep my decrees and my laws. The native-born and the aliens living among you must not do any of these detestable things, 27 for all these things were done by the people who lived in the land before you, and the land became defiled. 28 And if you defile the land, it will vomit you out as it vomited out the nations that were before you.

If anything we’re called to protect the Earth, and as Christians we should be at the forefront of Creation Care, instead of being swept up in the coat-tails.

email2friend
  • And we're done. Comments closed.
  • Veronica
    She knows how to do dishes???
  • Oh, mom....*sigh*
    Don't worry; you're always going to have to do our dishes.
  • Confused in Canton
    Seriously?! Can't we all just be happy? Thank you Matt for finding a new forum for the family kitchen table - all this fun and no one gets stuck with the dishes! Love you ALL bunches!
  • Veronica
    It's not arrogance, its hope.
  • J. Peaslee
    For sure, medical advances have come far and will continue to do so. But to think that we can solve anything...well, honey, that's just plain arrogance. ;) We will NEVER have enough money, resources, or research to accomplish everything. 50, 30, 10 years from now, people will look back on some of our so-called advances and laugh. If you don't believe me, just Google "phrenology."
  • Veronica
    May I point out to the darling J.Peaslee that medical advances from say 1900-2008 were full of oops and "that must really hurt"and now look at diseases that have been wiped out. My grandma would never believe a future where a surgeon could take your heart out of your body, fix it, put it back and send you home in a day or two. My point is with enough money and research, we can solve anything. So the light bulbs are a failure, science will keep trying to get it right. In the mean time we know all those little things help.(. I think I heard if its brown flush it down, if its yellow let it mellow. But what ever you think. Love you
  • J. Peaslee
    It's actually, "Why so serious?" ;)
    I'm not really trying to say, "DO NOTHING!" - see what I said about recycling and planting trees? Andrew kind of nailed it for me - would God be displeased with us for trying to save the earth, even if we made it worse? Probably not. So go ahead, flush the toilet only once a day & use those crazy new light bulbs, with their toxic mercury (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-506347/An-energy-saving-bulb-gone--evacuate-room-now.html).

    Storm windows? Hooray! Compost? A smart choice. Insulation? Don't see a problem with it. Car pools? Impractical sometimes…yet workable.

    But those light bulbs! Those are the big thing right now, you know. When they came out, everyone was excited. Even I was. Sounded good at the time. But now, you hear nothing but trouble about them! Just wondering how many other "solutions" actually make things worse.

    Be careful what you wish for. Our eagerness to make the world "better," without proper research before implementing new techniques to do so, are sometimes going to make things worse in the long run. Too many people jump on the bandwagon without knowing what they're getting into. If we're going to try and "save" the earth, why not try a little harder? Don't believe everything you hear/read.

    And no, that's not really directed towards anyone specifically - just in general.
  • Prescott
    JP, to quote the Dark Knight," Why so sad?". You have gone beyound to glass is half empty to the glass is broken and can't be repaired. "Do nothing!", now there is a plan for our future. Or I guess your saying that God created the world and who are we to question his work? Wouldn't he have made it perfect already so we are only harming that perfection.
  • I've got a lot of sympathy for J. Peaslee: if our approach to saving the planet actually does harm, then we are fools. (And energy-saving lightbulbs are a great example: they are very bad things). If it causes more people to starve (and the European approach to genetically-modified crops may be doing that) then we are worse than fools. Too much environmentalism is based on naive good will, rather than good science.

    On the other hand, I've never encountered anyone who thinks that trying to fix environmental problems flies in the face of God's purposes. Part of the purpose of the OT law is to ensure that the people live in harmony with their land, isn't it? Even if someone's view of eschatology is that Jesus will come again ... when the gospel has been preached to every nation ... it doesn't say he will come again when we've chopped down all the trees, or poisoned the oceans, or whatever else we're trying our best to achieve. The present age may be transient, but thinking that we may hasten its end by wanton destruction of creation, would be, well, perverse.

    I'm not sure if that's coherent. A different tack: do those who think that saving the planet is pointness also think that highway beautification, tidy neighbourhoods, etc. are pointless? After all, all those weeds and rubbish are signs of the fall, too. It's just that doing something about them doesn't hurt as much as taxing gas consumption.
  • J. Peaslee
    But haven't you noticed that we don't really know HOW to fix the earth? We think we're fixing it, and then we find out years later, "Oops, actually made it worse. My bad."
    Is it really the thought that counts? If, a hundred years from now, people look back and curse our generation because they figure out, I don't know, that those energy-saving light bulbs actually make things worse, are they going to say, "Oh, but that's okay, at least they tried"? No. Of course not.

    So that Bible verse, it's all nice and peachy, but what does it actually mean? We're going to defile the earth. It's our nature. We can't help it. And while there are some things that MUST be fine - things like recycling and planting trees - a lot of what we do to make it better...just makes it worse.
  • Prescott
    That was Veronica, I on the other hand say you work with idiots. And while I do not understand most of what was said, I do know that you better not wait around for others to do your work, or it won't get done. Love you!
  • Prescott
    First you tell the christian woman to get out of your way and then you eat the whale one bite at a time. Invite all your good and decent friends and God to come join the feast. V.
blog comments powered by Disqus
ramblings-theology-my thoughts